Sin Is Sin: A Theological Deep Dive into God’s Justice and Mercy
Exploring what Scripture really says about sin, justice, and the need for grace.
All Sin Is the Same?
Sin Is Sin: A Theological Deep Dive into God’s Justice and Mercy
Exploring what Scripture really says about sin, justice, and the need for grace.
SERIES:
All Sin Is the Same?
PART 1 OF 4
read state
Last Updated: August 29, 2025 at 1:32 PM ET
Does God Really See All Sin the Same?
It’s a question that has echoed through centuries of theological debate: Is all sin truly the same in God’s eyes? On the surface, this idea can feel both comforting and confusing. Comforting—because it implies a level playing field under grace. Confusing—because not all sins seem to have the same consequences. So what does Scripture actually teach?
📝 This post isn’t about justifying sin or minimizing its effects. It’s about rooting ourselves in the truth of God’s justice, holiness, and mercy—and gaining clarity in a world of moral confusion.
All Sin Separates Us from God
23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, (ESV)
Whether it’s a lie or a murder, a lustful glance or full-blown adultery, Scripture is crystal clear—all sin separates us from the presence of a holy God. The word “fall short” in the Greek is hystereō, meaning to lack, fail, or come behind. The standard is not “worse than others”—the standard is God Himself.
📝 God doesn’t grade sin on a human curve. He evaluates it by His perfect holiness.
This is why we need a Savior. Every human being—no matter their story—is guilty under the law and in need of redemption through Christ.
10 For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guilty of all of it. (ESV)
Yet Not All Sin Has Equal Consequence
While all sin equally separates us from God’s holiness, not all sin has the same result in our lives or in society.
11 Jesus answered him, “You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given you from above. Therefore he who delivered me over to you has the greater sin.” (ESV)
Jesus Himself refers to a “greater sin.” This tells us that although all sin is damning apart from grace, there are degrees of gravity, intent, and impact.
📝 Theft and murder are both sins—but one may destroy a relationship, and the other a life. God is aware of both the motive and the ripple effects.
God’s Justice Is Perfect—and So Is His Grace
14 Righteousness and justice are the foundation of your throne; steadfast love and faithfulness go before you. (ESV)
God does not ignore sin. His justice requires it be dealt with. But in Christ, He satisfies justice and extends mercy at the same time.
21 For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God. (ESV)
📝 The cross doesn’t make sin “not a big deal.” It proves just how big a deal it is—that God Himself paid the price for it.
What This Means for the Church Today
The idea that “all sin is the same” is often misused. It’s invoked to:
Avoid repentance (“Well, at least I’m not as bad as them.”)
Justify compromise (“All sin is equal, so don’t judge me.”)
Excuse hypocrisy (“Why call out this sin if you sin too?”)
But rightly understood, this doctrine levels the field at the foot of the cross. No one is righteous on their own. No one is beyond redemption. And no one has the right to stand in self-righteous judgment of others.
1 Therefore you have no excuse, O man, every one of you who judges. For in passing judgment on another you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, practice the very same things. (ESV)
Final Thought
God sees the heart. And the truth is, all sin—no matter how “small” or “private”—is cosmic treason against a holy King. But the beauty of the gospel is that He offers the same forgiveness to the murderer as He does to the gossip, the addict, the liar, and the lukewarm Christian.
When we embrace this truth, we don’t shrink from repentance—we run to it. We don’t compare our righteousness—we cling to Christ’s. And we don’t weaponize this truth to silence conviction—we use it to extend the same grace we’ve received.
Ask Yourself:
Have I secretly categorized certain sins as “worse” to make myself feel better about my own?
Do I truly understand that even my “small” sins put Christ on the cross?
Am I more interested in defending my sin—or repenting from it?
Join the Discussion:
How has your understanding of sin and grace changed as you’ve grown deeper in your walk with Christ?
#TheWholyChristian #TheRootedChristian #AllSinIsTheSame #GraceAndTruth #BiblicalTheology #SinAndSalvation